Perfect Brownie Review

Today I will review the Perfect Brownie for you wonderful readers – and let me just say, this was the first time my kids were happy to help with one of “Mommy’s writing projects.”

For starters, here is the official infomercial for the Perfect Brownie pan. Check it out below and we’ll go over all of the claims and how they shook out after the video!

Not just your average brownieRight out of the gate (or box, in this case) we had our first injury. I cut myself on the pan – specifically the bottom insert. In the pan’s defense, I accidentally cut myself in the kitchen at least once a week (okay, okay … once a day). The directions are simple, in that it’s obvious how the 3 parts fit together (the 4th piece is the cooling rack), but I was already a tad annoyed that there would just be more parts to clean. Yes, the Perfect Brownie Pan is dishwasher safe, but my dishwasher is pretty much always full with 4 kids in the house.

Let’s get down to business now: the Perfect Brownie Pan Set comes with a recipe booklet, or simply use your favorite boxed mix and follow those instructions. Be sure to spray all three pieces with cooking spray and follow the directions that come with your Perfect Brownie Pan Set. It is suggested that you place the entire assembled Perfect Brownie Pan on a baking sheet to prevent any leak. I didn’t have any issues with leaks, but I wasn’t going to take any chances.

Once the brownies had cooked and cooled for a few minutes, I removed the divider and then placed the pan on the rack. Now, you are supposed to easily slide the pan down, leaving only the inside base on the rack to cool. It wasn’t quite this smooth and I did almost drop the whole batch of brownies on the ground, but again, I am clumsy by nature.

The Verdict

I didn’t notice a change in taste from any of my other batches in the past in various pans, but I was pleased right away with how clean and uniform each brownie piece was, thanks to the divider in the Perfect Brownie Pan. This would be especially useful when entertaining or giving baked goods as a gift. I say baked goods because you can really use this pan for a variety of baked goods. I also made pumpkin bread squares and they came out adorable and delicious. With the pumpkin squares I used the stencils included with the Perfect Brownie Pan Set to stencil a turkey with powdered sugar – great for a Thanksgiving Day Buffet!

Overall, I was pleased – minus the cut on my arm and the extra parts to wash – it was worth it to get professional-looking baked goods and for $19.99, that’s a steal if it means it will keep you from buying expensive store-bought baked goods in the future.


Do you have specific questions about Perfect Brownie? Have you already ordered the Perfect Brownie Pan Set and would like to know the status of your order? Here is Perfect Brownie’s customer service information:

Customer service is available Monday through Friday from 8:00am to 10:00pm Eastern Time. You can also check your order status 24 hours a day at

Perfect Brownie™ Customer Service
P.O. Box 3179
Wallingford, CT 06494

Official Website:
Phone: 1-800-664-2590

Comments are closed.